ReviewThe success of the course depends to a large degree on the participation of the students and their ability to critically evaluate a research paper. To ensure this quality, we ask every student to submit a short review of each paper to Canvas the day before the lecture where this paper will be discussed. Reviewing GuidelinesPeer review is an important part of science and engineering. Understanding the review process will make you a better writer. The task of the referee is outlined in this article by Alan Jay Smith. Although you will not be making recommendations for or against publication, use the questions listed in Section 4 of Smith's article to guide the review writing process. A good review should be one-page long and include several parts. In your review, address the following points:
GradingSubmitting reviews for all papers in the class is worth 20% of your final grade. The reviews will be graded based on the following criteria:
SubmissionYou will need to submit the following no later than 11:59pm before the day the paper will be discussed.
|